Home

We all know how great Nagawicka Lake is and that’s why there is so much Buyer Interest in Homes and Properties on Nagawicka and that’s why the inventory on the Lake goes so fast.

What I do, is watch this market immediately around Nagawicka Lake and try to put my Buyers in the Best Position as soon as I have any indication that a property is coming to market. I’m proactive with mailings and Postcards. Often these properties are brokered prior to them even coming to market; they don’t actually come to “MarketPlace” (on Zillow). I will try to bring you options that your realtor wont…

Because my commission isn’t always guaranteed if a property isn’t listed for sale, I need my clients to remember that I will need a 2.4% commission. Often a seller is happy to pay my commission when asked to do so in an Offer To Purchase.

Sylvester was my Grandfather.
Sylvester Price and his Brother, Leo bought 18 acres of land in 1921 from a farmer on Nagawicka Lake. The land borders are Price road straight west to the lake and then again bordered by the Park River & Nagawicka Rd. They bought it somewhat as an investment but soon made into the summer retreat from the city. The 2 brothers were also partners in Price Erecting started in Milwaukee. They agreed to subdivide the parcel and gave many of these lake lots to people and business with whom the company did business with, i.e. Harnischfeger, Masterson Steel & original Briggs & Stratton. These parcels where eventually resold thru the years. At the end there was land east of the lake that Sylvester kindly gave to all of the parcels that were divided.

Today it just looks like a planned subdivision out lot. Those owners were very grateful and when the time came to names those roads, they agreed to name the road after Sylvester. Family lore has it that this parcel was previously sold for a sum of two horses in the 1800’s.

Homes for sale on Nagawicka Lake

Address / MLS #List PriceBedrooms
3513 Ridge Dr
Delafield, WI
$1,699,0003
1603 Milwaukee St
Delafield, WI
$949,9992
2717 Ridley Rd
Delafield, WI
$1,200,0002
3024 Nagawicka Ave
Delafield, WI
$1,679,9004
1722 Journeys Dr
Delafield, WI
$794,9004
3513 Ridge Dr
Delafield, WI
$1,699,000


As Legend has it, Lake Nagawicka was named in the early 1800s by land Explorer and surveyor Jean-Luc Mon Cher. The term “Nagawicka” means little Indian (or petite Indian) in the Indian/ French dialect of the day. Contemporary musician, Jacky Galou has put this traditional French Story to song. Click on the link below for the French song Nagawicka



Homes

Condos

Vacant Land

Below is a list of properties that sold on Nagawicka Lake in the last 18 months. Reading the comps can sometimes be tricky. If you want me to compare these comps with a property that's currently on the market, let me know and I will give you my suggestion on pricing of current listings.

SOLD ADDRESSSOLD PRICESOLD DATEBedsLiving Area
3112 Nagawicka Ave
$1,350,0002023-06-1642,629 sqft
3202 Nagawicka Ave
$845,0002023-08-0132,276 sqft
2012 W Shore Dr
$965,0002023-06-1631,600 sqft
2842 Nagawicka Ave
$800,0002023-08-3141,200 sqft
2713 Burries Rd
$2,750,0002023-09-1154,992 sqft
3118 Nagawicka Ave
$650,0002023-10-132884 sqft
820 Back Bay Rd
$3,000,0002024-06-0537,181 sqft
608 St Johns Dr
$1,064,5002023-11-2143,123 sqft
2420 Woodland Park Dr
$915,0002024-08-0232,250 sqft
2634 Nagawicka Ave
$1,225,0002024-10-0943,399 sqft
2307 Nagawicka Rd
$2,950,0002024-07-0955,019 sqft
2718 Nagawicka Ave
$650,0002024-09-0642,157 sqft
615 Garrison Ct
$3,595,0002025-05-3044,526 sqft
3249 Sylvester Dr
$1,220,0002024-11-0133,682 sqft
2813 Ridley Rd
$1,015,0002024-09-2621,435 sqft
2378 Lakeview Ct
$1,250,0002024-09-3042,030 sqft
W328N4236 Starboard Dr
$640,0002025-01-1043,416 sqft
2818 Nagawicka Ave
$1,250,0002024-10-1732,377 sqft
3007 Sylvester Dr
$1,000,0002024-11-012832 sqft
1451 Main St
$555,0002025-05-0933,128 sqft
2905 Sylvester Dr
$1,940,0002025-03-3143,427 sqft
N38W32690 Edgewood Ct
$435,0002025-04-082824 sqft
2107 Evergreen Ln
$2,050,0002025-06-1843,911 sqft
N41W32668 Marina Dr
$615,0002025-05-3032,644 sqft
923 Lake Dr
$2,000,0002025-05-3044,000 sqft
1347 Mariner Dr
$3,675,0002025-07-2535,068 sqft
1542 3rd St
$470,0002025-08-2931,761 sqft
1504 Milwaukee St
$735,0002025-07-0841,732 sqft
900 Hawks Hollow -
$2,450,0002025-06-2775,000 sqft
2132 W Shore Dr
$1,300,0002025-08-0653,792 sqft
1534 Milwaukee St
$450,0002025-08-262851 sqft
3321 Lake Dr
$2,100,0002025-08-2932,556 sqft
1503 Milwaukee St
$3,175,0002025-12-0545,498 sqft
N41W32881 Neptune Bight -
$750,0002026-01-0844,030 sqft
2135 W Shore Dr
$640,0002026-03-0332,167 sqft
2736 Nagawicka Ave
$500,0002026-03-312900 sqft
Listing Data Source: MetroMLS. Copyright 2025 MetroMLS - All Rights Reserved Information is supplied by seller and other third parties and has not been verified.